Today I spent a great deal of time debugging a few things in UnifyingResolutions. For one, often, when resolvents are computed by Skeptik, I have an extra formula in my antecedent, and of course this should not be happening. Furthermore, I am concerned about the symmetry of UnifyingResolutions, as when I make unit tests with the same proof nodes, say A,B passed as (A,B), it works fine, but (B,A) does not ("Resolution: the conclusions of the given premises are not resolvable."). This is apparently fine in practice though, so I'm dropping this concern for now.
The concern I was having was regarding extra antecedents in my code (and possibly extra succedents--though I haven't yet observed this, likely by luck/not looking past extra antecdents). Bruno has identified this as an error in filtering some formulas in the resolvent, and so there's hope for a (relatively) quick fix.
No comments:
Post a Comment